Reasons why Scar and Zira aren't related

Reasons why Scar and Zira aren't related


OK, I once heard a theory about Scar and Zira being related. This is why it isn't possible



First of all, I would like to say that I am not pointing at anyone here, because I don't mean anyone in particular. But one theory I heard was that Scar and Zira may be related. I'm sorry, but how does that work? Let me go over it.



"Scar and Zira must be related, because they look like each other!"



If you mean through colours, then not possible



"What? But Mufasa and Scar don't look alike, and they are brothers!"



Exactly. Scar and Mufasa are brothers. That is canon. By saying that Zira is Scar's sister, that also makes her Mufasa's sister. And Zira being Mufasa and Scar's sister is not canon as far as I can see. Lets look at this. If Zira was Scar's sister, and Scar killed Mufasa and chased Simba away, do you really think that Zira would worship him like that?



"Well, Zira might have hated Mufasa and Simba!"



And why would that be? She might hate Mufasa for maybe being mean to Scar in the past, but I doubt it. And also, she might hate Simba because he was the son of Mufasa, but she wouldn't want him to die just because of that. I mean, that's too immature, even for Zira.



Why else could Zira hate Mufasa and Simba? Obviously for the same reason as Scar, wanting to be queen. In that case, wouldn't she be plotting against him, too? He would be in the way of Zira becoming queen. She wouldn't fan over him like that now, would she? So that's one reason why Scar and Zira = Brother and Sister is impossible.



"Scar and Zira have the same body build! That must mean that they are related!"



That isn't a good reason, either. All outlanders have a skinny build. I'm sure that Vitani does, and Nuka. Does that make them the brother and sister of Scar as well? Of course not. Again bringing in Mufasa and Scar. Mufasa does not have a skinny build, and he is Scar's brother. They do not have to look alike to be related. So that does not prove that Zira is Scar's sister, either.



"Well they have the same noses, don't they? They must be related!"



Let's take a closer look at the outlanders. They all have outlander noses. Mufasa, once again, does not have an outlander nose, but he is related to Scar. Technically if you look at it they don't even have the same outlander nose.



"What do you mean? Of course they do!"



No, they don't. And this is why. Please look at the following two images.





Am I the only one who sees a difference? With Scar's nose, the inner part is more, how do I put this, round maybe? And Zira's nose on the inside is much straighter. Clearly getting rid of that theory.



"Well, they have chin tuffs! They have to be related!"



Once again, not possible. Yes, they have chin tuffs, but if you look at the images above, Zira's is different to Scar's. Scar's seems to be going in, towards his mane. Zira's is much smaller, and it goes out. Deleting that theory. In fact, if you also look, thet don't even have the same eyes. I know the eye colour is different, but I didn't mean that/ Look at the eyelids. Look at the upper eye and lower eye. Zira's is pointing more to her ears while Scar's seems to be pointing more to the top of his mane.



Now lets look at a few other things.



Assuming that Nuka is Scar and Zira's cub (a hint that we get from the quote "Kovu Kovu Kovu, Scar wasn't even his father, he just took him in.") if Scar and Zira were siblings, then surely it would be wrong for them to have a cub together? I am well aware that in the wild lions mate with their families all the time but this is a children's film. I'm pretty sure that they are supposed to represent humans more than real lions.



"And I his loving devoted queen." A quote from Zira in a deleted scene. If Scar and Zira were siblings, why would Scar make Zira his queen? He wouldn't, that's the point.



Now then. Scar chose Kovu to be the next king, right? And Zira mothers him, am I correct? Why would Scar ask his sister to raise a child that was the chosen one instead of asking another lioness? Let's think about this. Zira trains Kovu to become the next king, and it looks a lot to me like she wants to try and impress Scar's spirit. She wouldn't do that if she was his sister. She would try and get revenge herself, not make his chosen one do it. However, if she was his mate, or a fangirl, she would snap up the offer without a seond thought, right? She would be happy to follow it the way that Scar wanted her to (sorry, you're probably lost now) because she wanted to do everything his way. I can't see a sister doing that.



I hope that things are a little clearer on this matter now. If you still think that they are siblings, then that's fine. I'm not trying to change anyone's opinion, just show them why it couldn't be and let them decide for themselves. Oh, and try to keep things friendly down there in the comments. I mean, there's no need to get into an argument over something that doesn't really matter. It won't make it the end of the world, right?



Rebekah_the_Lion







42303 visits

Report this article Report this article

Last comments

April 14, 2015
Is not currently on the site
She is said to be just a follower, not his sister or mate. Because if she were scar his mate then kiara and kovu would be cousins and one of the directors thought that would be very wrong for a children's film. They did plan to make Zira Scar's mate but changed it in the middle of production.

June 20, 2013
Usa Is not currently on the site
Secretly a fairy
If you notice in the second movie (I watched carefully for any errors) during the war scene before and after Vitani states that Kiara is right, two of the Outlander lioness have PRIDELANDER noses! And if you look even more, the most of them have Pridelander noses! This jumped out saying my name and I never noticed it until now.

March 04, 2013
Uk Is not currently on the site
JeanZedlav: You have a good point (and an interesting theory) but, although that scene was deleted, it doesn't make it any less official. And she didn't technically have to become his mate, she could have been a fangirl, it still gives her a reason to say that.
Also, Zira didn't know that Simba would come back. She either didn't know he existed or thought he was dead (depending on where Zira was in the first film) so she would have no reason to need a male to help her fight Simba. To her, Scar was going to rule until he died of old age and then his heir would take the throne, and the circle would start again.

JeanZedlav
JeanZedl
av
February 24, 2013
Is not currently on the site
You have a good point with physical differences, but again, every point you make, you also have to admit that it could go the other way. Zira doesn't have the same features as Scar, but then, neither does Mufasa.

My theory:Zira was Scar's daughter, raised in the Pridelands before leaving to search for a mate/another Pride. She returned during his reign, with with Nuka as a cub, or pregnant. She was accepted into the Pride, but she didn't know Scar was her father. In the movie, it's never mentioned she was his Queen(I don't count the deleted scene because it was stated in an interview that they were never mates).

And even if she was his sister and had the same reasons as Taka to hate Mufasa, then it still makes sense that she needed a male to fight Simba. If her lionesses didn't help, she wouldn't stand a chance against him. Lionesses are much smaller and lighter than lions, and are easily beaten in a fight with an (censored) male who wants to kill them. Her best bet would be for a male loyal to her to fight Simba.

ZeltoreoTheLion
Zeltoreo
TheLion
December 23, 2012
Is not currently on the site
well scar got his color and looks from his mom and mufasa got his color from his father and looks and scar got some of his looks from ahadi to PS ahadi and uru are there parents

CARLOSS
CARLOSS
December 23, 2012
Is not currently on the site
dzjdsd:) :( ░x░ ░x░

November 05, 2012
Uk Female Is not currently on the site
ex mod, cheeky sod
this is an interesting article I totally agree with you about how they clearly are not related. If they where related, then the lion king 2 would barely make any sense. About how nuka is scars cub, I'm not saying he isn't, but according to your nose theory (thats what I like to call itlol ) nuka has a slightly different nose than scar if you look closely. but like you said about scar and mufasa, they are officially related but they have completely different noses. so well done!

SarabiMirage123
SarabiMi
rage123
November 03, 2012
Is not currently on the site
Thank you for someone finally pointing this out! Yes, they have the same strcuture, bla bla bla... but look what they don't have in common. Fur colour, eye colour, eye shape, face shape, schin shape paw colouring. You are a genius!

October 29, 2012
Brazil Is not currently on the site
I never believed Scar and Zira were siblings (and I don't even think they are at all), but people believe this theory because of an error in Disney's website: Zira was stated as being not only Mufasa's and Scar's sister but also Kovu's step-mother and aunt.

Blue Eyes
Blue
Eyes
October 24, 2012
Is not currently on the site
I don't even think the fur colour is alike. ░x░ You don't have to look like someone to related to them. That's like saying because two people have golden hair they must be siblings, or whatever.




Not connected : To be able to post a message site, you must be connected.

Register on the site!

The Lion King reads and more


Site activity




Franšais   English

RSS      Bookmark the site      Privacy policy      27 visitors connected

Generated in 0.298 seconds

To give you the best experience, this site uses cookies. By continuing, you're giving consent to cookies being used. Learn more... Close X